Tags
“Give it to me.”
The first time I heard it was on a date. Still in high school, I was flattered and thrilled when the guy I met at the dance said he was already in college. We went out a few times, group things like football games and friends’ parties. He asked me to dinner, and after the pizza said he wanted to swing by his parents’ house. When we got there, he acted surprised that nobody was home, but invited me in anyway. The necking was almost immediately rough. I said I needed to go home, and the next thing I knew we were on the floor, my hands trapped, and his teeth biting hard, mashing into my mouth. I tried to shout, but my voice came out in a whisper. “Please.”
Somehow I was sitting up, arms wrapped around myself. He brought me some ice in a towel, and told me he’d take care of me. When my mouth stopped bleeding, I said I was tired and asked him to take me home. I remember that I said “please”. When we got to my house, he kissed my cheek, said again how sorry he was, and started to get out of the car. I told him my parents were probably still up and that I’d go in alone.
All I could think of was that I wasn’t supposed to be at a guy’s house if his parents weren’t home, so I told my mother we’d been kissing a little hard and that I just needed to put ice on it. I wore high-necked, long-sleeved shirts to hide the bruises that blossomed by morning. The next day, a huge bouquet of flowers arrived. First time I got flowers. My mother put them on a table in the living room, and I didn’t enter that room again for the two weeks it took them to die. My friends said I was lucky—with me being alone with him at his house, it could have been worse. I didn’t feel lucky.
“Give it to me.”
The difference was that this time I knew it was going to hurt. The mugger wanted the wallet in my hands. It was late night on the south side of Chicago, where I was in college. When he punched me in the mouth, I dropped the wallet. The police officer who took my report in the emergency room (as the doctor stitched my mouth and taped what would be a scar on my chin) said I was lucky—with me being “someplace I shouldn’t”, it could have been worse. I still didn’t feel lucky.
But it’s taken me years to realize that those were the same crime. Those experiences stole precious things from me. For years, I was nervous about dating, about going out after dark, or being in any situation where I might again be “lucky”.
The message was that it was my fault. My fault for voluntarily being in the wrong place at the wrong time. I never thought about whether that was true or not, until I had daughters of my own. My daughter was away at University when I got a call. She’d been crossing the street—on a sunny morning in a marked crosswalk—when another student in a convertible hit her. She went flying, landing on her head. She was lying there bleeding, with head and hip injuries that would take years to heal, when the police officer (after first comforting the sobbing driver who’d run her down) told her that she was lucky. Lucky that her long hair had been pinned to the back of her head, softening the impact. Lucky that she wasn’t dead. She told him that she could have been more unlucky, but lucky people don’t get hit by cars.
I was thinking of this when I heard that Malala Yousafzai won the Nobel Peace Prize. The announcer on the radio said that Malala had been “lucky” to survive the Taliban gunmen who boarded her school bus and shot her in the head, or those who issue streams of threats.
“We will kill you in such a harsh way that no woman has so far been killed in that manner.”
Hell, no. That’s not luck.
Lucky is not having to worry about whether your failure to say no loud enough and often enough means you are saying yes, like Emma Sulkowicz who is carrying her mattress around campus to protest Columbia University’s failure to discipline the student she says raped her, despite similar complaints from his other victims.
Lucky is doing a professional job without an unending stream of anonymous rape and death threats because you’re a woman like Zoe Quinn and Anita Sarkeesian in a troll-dominated field such as game development. And lucky is not fleeing your own home like Briana Wu, head of development at Giant Spacekat, following last night’s violent threats against her and her family listing her address and personal information.
“Women are the niggers of gender,” the email said. “If you killed yourself, I wouldn’t even fuck the corpse.”
I blinked at my phone, fighting simultaneous urges to hurl my phone across the room in anger and cry. Later that day, someone texted me my address — telling me they’d “See me when I least expected it.” —Opinion by Brianna Wu
You know what? Malala and these other young women are not lucky. They’re brave. Brave enough to stand up and fight for their rights to education, to control their own bodies, to equal opportunities, and to defy those who threaten them with rape and death for doing so.
I think it’s time for all of us to stop being so lucky and start being mad.
Brilliant, disturbing and so damn true. I am so sorry to hear about your ghastly experiences, and those of your daughter. I can very much identify with what you are saying, having been sexually attacked by a stranger back in 1988. The glibness of ‘lucky’ in such circumstances has always struck me as offensive and patronising – and I think your ‘start being mad’ comment is one a great many people would agree with.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I don’t know any women who haven’t had similar experiences to some degree. The cost to them and to all of us, is in what does NOT happen next—the adventures, creativity, exploration, growth we do NOT experience—because we don’t want someone to again tell us we’re lucky that bad things weren’t worse.
LikeLike
Excellent post!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you! I appreciate hearing from you.
LikeLike
..fabulous post, m’Lady 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
So sorry you and your daughter had to suffer through that crap. I was raped once by an acquaintance. He followed me home from a party, knocked on my door and pushed his way in when I answered the door in my robe.I reported it to the police. I admitted I had been drinking but was not drunk. I was told if I hang around with drunks I have to expect it. They didn’t even charge the guy, but wanted to send me to survivor classes. My own family told me it happens in all communities and I just needed to be more careful. The guy raped again. AGAIN he was not charged. Only after he was caught with drugs did he go to jail…briefly, I’ll add. Then he moved away to do it somewhere else. Sick.
LikeLike
Obviously, I can’t hit “like” on this one. I’m so so SO sorry that you’ve had to go through such a devastating experience. And I’m absolutely furious that you, the victim, was blamed by every social structure that should have been supporting you.
The sad part, of course, is that all of them—police, family, community—would say they did support you, and that their blame was actually their way of making sure you didn’t have to be so “lucky” again. I’ll bet it worked too. How many dates did you avoid, perfectly nice invitations did you decline, or exciting opportunities did you now pass up in the name of being more “careful”?
LikeLike
Well, I never went to or left a bar alone after that and I never opened my door in my robe…whether I “knew” the person or not.
I do get angry, AM angry. And the energy of that anger has no way to be released. I got very involved with the national Organization for Women (NOW) but the radical extremists drove me away.
When my own daughter was being abused by a guy she was running with and came home black and blue, I took her in and forbid her to have any contact with him. I required her to get the cops involved and just dared them to drop it. I wanted him to know his behavior was criminal. I wanted her to know I valued her.
LikeLike
Great post! How sad that nothing seems to change…women are always made to feel like somehow it was their fault.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have to believe that things CAN change and that they will. It’s a lesson I learned from my brave and brilliant daughters. “I could be more UN-lucky, but this shit doesn’t happen to lucky people.” They teach me every day.
LikeLike
Amazing post. You said all that really needed to be said, and what is so true in these situations. Too bad most people don’t get it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks so much for these kind words. It’s a lesson I’ve learned from my own daughters. I can’t make other people “get it”, but I CAN stop blaming the victims.
LikeLike
I’m lucky that I’ve never been “lucky” in either of these ways. That doesn’t mean I’m not mad for those who have been lucky.
Beautifully expressed, Barb.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks so much for your mad. We could use more of that!
LikeLike
Well said Barb. A shame it needs to be said though – still. Reminds me of Alice Sebold’s ‘Lucky’, which she wrote after being raped and being told she was ‘lucky’ not to have been murdered. Putting the blame firmly on the perpetrators is long overdue.
LikeLiked by 1 person
You’re right of course and I hope we’re getting closer to assigning blame where it belongs. But the thing we need to do first, the one thing we CAN do, is stop accepting blame ourselves.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Alison Williams Writing and commented:
A thought-provoking post from Barb Taub’s blog – and one I wholeheartedly agree with.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks so much for the reblog!
LikeLike
A brave, blunt post which reminds us that there is still tremendous injustice and danger for women all around the world. Thanks Barb
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thank you so much for these very kind words!
LikeLike
A very sad and disturbing post and I feel so sorry and angry that women are still treated so very unjustly. It’s way past time the right people took the blame and paid for their crimes. Reblogged on BetweenTheLines
LikeLiked by 1 person
Belated thanks for the reblog. I continue to be optimistic as I see what our daughters (and sons) are doing to change things, even though it means pushing that boulder up that mountain.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Reblogged this on and commented:
A very sad and disturbing post…let’s start being mad!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pingback: Coffee with Barb & @Alison_WiIliams ~ Rape: A Mother, Wife, and Feminist Writes #SundayBlogShare | Barb Taub