Tags
2020, Black Lives Matter, coronavirus, covid-19, facemasks, masks, protest, stages of grief, year 2020
2020: This year has a LOT to answer for.
My friend Sarah was talking about who has suffered most during the past year. People in their sixties like us don’t have as much to lose, she pointed out. Our kids are grown, we have financial security, and many of us are looking at another twenty-plus years of good health and freedom to pursue our interests. But people in their eighties and above have had to give up what might be their last chance to travel or explore interests. And perhaps with the longest-reaching consequences, young people and especially young women, have seen their lives put on hold— education interrupted, jobs lost, weddings cancelled or postponed, devastating choices made between providing for and taking care of their children.
For families and friends of over a million pandemic victims worldwide, 2020 meant the ultimate personal loss and bereavement.
For the rest of the world, experiencing the year 2020 has also meant a grieving process similar to the stages described by Dr. Elizabeth Kübler Ross: denial, anger, bargaining, depression, acceptance.
Denial:
Cognitive scientist Dr. Adrian Bardon (Professor of Philosophy, Wake Forest University) says that in an increasingly politically divided world, science and facts are denied in favor of “Motivated reasoning”—the process of deciding what evidence to accept based on the conclusion one prefers.

A man smokes a cigarette with his eyes covered by a face mask as he takes part in a protest against the use of protective masks during the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic, in Madrid, Spain. [Image credit: Reuters Connect/Juan Medina]. SCORE: Spain, 31,232 Covid deaths in 2020. So far…
Anger
Following highly-publicized incidents of police violence, an infuriated America began to spontaneously protest unequal standards of policing and racial justice. Americans realized the country they thought they lived in wasn’t real for a huge number of their fellow citizens. Hundreds of thousands joined peaceful protests, which were often accompanied by rioting, bloodshed, and violence. Black Lives Matter protests were echoed across the globe.
Bargaining
The science is clear. Expert opinion is plentiful. Until there’s a vaccine, the best defense against the pandemic is a combination of social distancing, mask wearing, and contact tracing. As economies melted down around the world, it was often the most highly-developed countries who made political bargains, bowed to pressures to lift lockdown, failed contact tracing, loosened economic and social distancing requirements.
The UK took the bargaining approach, effectively saying people could do whatever they wanted, but they hoped they would want to do what the government wanted them to do. When Prime Minister Boris Johnson was asked specifically why the UK was failing compared to countries like Germany and Italy, he replied:
“Actually, there is an important difference between our country and many other countries around the world. That is that our country is a freedom loving country.” He continued, “And it is very difficult to ask the British population uniformly to obey guidelines in the way that is necessary.”
Unimpressed, Italian President Sergio Mattarella had a pithy (and rhyming!) response: “Anche noi italiani amiamo la libertà ma abbiamo a cuore anche la serietà”. (“We Italians also love freedom, but we also care about seriousness.”)
Sadness, Depression
The Motherhood-tax is one of the biggest, best-hidden taxes of all. As Amanda Taub reports for the New York Times, the pandemic has the potential to eliminate women’s hard-won economic gains of the past decade. Work from home, no matter how employers embrace the concept, overwhelmingly means working mothers lose their childcare support system, and are now juggling two fulltime roles, parent and provider. The emotional and financial consequences reach far beyond the lockdown itself, with lifetime income reductions of 39% for a one year absence from the workforce and 65% reduction for employment gaps of four years or more. “Around the world, working women are facing brutally hard choices about whether to stay home if they haven’t already been laid off.”
Acceptance
One of my sisters told me her neighbors put a sign in her yard supporting an extremely conservative political candidate. She removed it multiple times and finally threw it away. To her shock, her neighbors screamed at her, shaking with rage, and insisting they had the right to display signs in her yard because theirs couldn’t be seen from the street, shaking their fist and yelling, “F*** YOU!”
In her sixty years, my sister said, she’d never had anyone say that to her. I told her I wasn’t sure what was the weirdest part of the story—that the neighbors thought they had rights to her yard, or that it’s the first time someone hurled the f-bomb at her. Other siblings offered suggestions about the police and video records.
But it was my sister who has spent decades teaching middle school kids from some of Los Angeles’ most challenging neighborhoods who really made me stop and think about anger and how to live with its fallout. She told us about stopping earlier that day to help a young mother with a flat tire, and how other cars just honked and yelled at them for being in the way. The young woman didn’t have breakdown coverage, so my sister used her own card to call for help. Her message to the rest of us was simple. “…just go find something nice to do for another person as a way to pass on good energy. Let your neighbor deal with her own bad karma.”
I hope I can come out of 2020 the way my sister suggested. I hope I can help others and let the ones I can’t reach stew in their own bad karma. But either way, I know I’ll still grieve for not only the family and friends who have died unfairly early and before anyone could have prepared for it, but also a world and a past that has, in so many ways, died as well.
A most excellent post. I’ve always believed that there was too little kindness in this world and to do what I could to change that. However, if I’m being honest, there are certain persons that would be most difficult to include. I’ve no doubt you wouldn’t have to think long and hard on this…
Write that letter, pick up that phone and just tell those you love that you do indeed love them. There are no guarantees at any age.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Such wise advice! And probably more long-term satisfaction than what you and I would want to do to ‘certain persons’.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I do believe that there are limitations on the types of things one can say on WP so I won’t go there. I’m sure with your imagination you will have no problem with the message…
Actually, while a number of us would like to see several individuals in orange jumpsuits, I honestly believe Bellvue would be more appropriate. Straight jackets and padded walls and no “get out of jail free cards.”
BTW, as long as a certain individual has come into the conversation, I didn’t get your read on what they called a debate? I think they should immediately replace Chris Wallace with Katie Porter and go from there. 😉
LikeLike
Thank you for this post. I have a lot of these thoughts in my head but my ability to articulate them in a sensible order is limited. Good Job.
LikeLiked by 1 person
All thanks to Sarah and Cathy!
LikeLike
I think you’ve hit it right on the head – it distresses me that what I feel most about our country right now is sadness. And frustration. When we were created, we were given brains meant to be used for reasoning and thought. Apparently we’ve forgotten that.
LikeLiked by 1 person
When I was heading up HR, I used to warn interviewers against the Halo Effect. In other words, if a job applicant hits a home run on one important point, there is a tendency to ignore their potential mismatches and unsuitable facets. We look at our politicians the same way. If someone echoes our social agenda, we tend to completely ignore everything else they say or do, no matter how appalling.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, when I think about it, I’m sure I do the same. But never before have we had someone in office with so many glaring uglies. As I see it. 🙄
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think we are going to emerge fomr 202 having gone through the most anxiety filled years – the pandemic, having to move – but since I am a fervent believer in a glass half full, I look forward to better days. The pendulum will swing back as it always does. A good sensible list, Barb.
LikeLiked by 1 person
A lovely attitude Noele! We could all learn from you. (Well… maybe learn AFTER the election?)
LikeLiked by 1 person
Great points! Everyone is at different stages right now. I have been seeing more people at the acceptance stage lately which is good. We have to learn to live with this as best as we can and We may as well be kind about it. Bravo to your sister.
LikeLiked by 1 person
My sister is kind of a miracle. She’s been through an incredibly tough life, and come out of it with this positive attitude and all this wisdom.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I don’t believe I have gone through any of these stages. I live in a country that has been beset by economic and political turmoil for years and nothing is definite in our lives so it hasn’t been that hard to adapt to this change for us. It’s just more of the same long-term uncertainty. I can imagine that for people in Britain who had a stable and reliable life, this has been devastating. It is a question of perspective, I suppose.
LikeLiked by 1 person
We have friends who moved to our little Scottish island from S. Africa. Their stories about what it can be like there on an everyday basis leave us stunned. (How do you feel about moving to Scotland?)
LikeLiked by 2 people
It is very interesting that you should ask that particular question, Barb. My oldest son is applying to Edinburg University for 2022. If he gets in, we will be moving to Scotland. I can’t wait.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Two of my children went to Edinburgh. Not only did they get a fabulous education, but one of them married a fellow student, and they now have two children. I have a lot of reasons to appreciate Edinburgh University. Good luck to your son! And please make sure to visit us as soon as you get here.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Of course, thank you, Barb, and for the feedback on the Uni.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Maybe one of these days I’ll grieve. I just want to wake up from the freakin’ nightmare. This can’t be real. There’s no place like home, there’s no place like home… ‘Second star to the right and straight on ’til morning. ‘ … Hugs on the wing.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I haven’t made it all the way through the stages yet either.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The rise in nastiness in this country (US) and I guess the rest of the world is so disturbing that I wonder if this corvid virus doesn’t affect the brains of some people.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m hearing this from people all over the States. They say the atmosphere is just full of anger, but it’s more. People who wouldn’t have felt it was acceptable to behave in such overtly racist, discriminatory, and/or sexist ways have somehow decided it’s okay now. Sadly, all this means is the hate they’ve felt all along is now ‘safe’ to display publicly.
I’d like to believe the hundreds of thousands who have been publicly and peacefully protesting will make a difference. But sadly, before that happens I fear that the newly-emboldened public haters will fight back.
LikeLike
I’m afraid I’m stuck at the anger stage. At 83 I grocery shop at 6 am to avoid crowds. I was coming down the aisle when three grown young men all over six feet tall were walking abreast toward me without masks. I am five feet tall. They were laughing and obviously proud of their rebellion against mask wearing. They were also blocking the aisle by walking together. Something snapped in me and I put my head down and picked up speed pushing my buggy straight at them. They scattered at the last minute. They picked on the wrong little old lady.
LikeLiked by 5 people
You rock Eileen! Oh for a video of that little scene…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks Barb,
We had a Mass for Jean at our old parish, St. Patrick’s. The Priest tried to make it as traditional as possible, though everyone wore masks. It made me realize how much the COVD19 virus restrictions have affected so many of our normal social conventions – church attendence, weddings and even funerals. I think our authorities need to express as much concern for the people’s need to socialize as the isolationist efforts to control the virus.
I miss Jean. I find myself picking up the phone to talk with her. Joe
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think the loss of social contact is going to leave the world with PTSD. There’s a reason that people have come together to share joy and pain since the dawn of time, and denying those basic human needs will leave scars that may never heal. I was SO sorry I couldn’t be there for Jean’s memorial service, or for the other family members we lost that same week. Their memories are beautiful, but the lack of social support at such sad time is a critical loss.
LikeLike
Barb, you express what I feel too. Every morning, I wake and think: one step further back towards the time when my grandparents were shoved into a cattle truck and shipped out to a camp. For those of us with memories or who grew up with the tales of the horror that was 1930s Germany, we are walking the same path. Black, Jew, EU Citizen, our lives are being diminished. I cling on to the hope that some express, but I am afraid I fear it will be a long long time in coming to fruition.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s an ancient strategy–create a scapegoat as the “danger” and then people will allow whatever it takes to be protected from that. Hearing the President of the United States telling “suburban housewives” they are in danger, and then telling white supremacists like Proud Boys to “stand back and stand by” is chilling. But that kind of blustery saber rattling is most dangerous because it hides a stealthy dismantling of democratic necessities like access to voting. And that’s truly terrifying.
LikeLike
Spot on, Barb! Thanks for this very clear analysis. I can only echo the sentiments expressed above – we have regressed past the point of return, I’m afraid.
LikeLiked by 1 person
We’re on a dangerous path, it’s true. But I hope and believe we haven’t passed the point of no return. I still think we can be the America we believed we already were–and this time, maybe we can get it right.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Praying hard!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Reblogged this on Thorne Moore.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m working on channelling the theme of a Jerry Seinfeld gag to the effect that if you’re being given the Finger by some of life’s vicissitudes, try and remember you are but one finger away from a Thumb’s Up. As for the pendulum swing, I worry when I visualise myself swinging on a pendulum that it comes across as a rather disturbing parody of Miley Cyrus on that wrecking ball…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Picturing you twerking on a wrecking ball… Nope, nope, nope. Now I have to go bleach my brain.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sorry Barb.
LikeLike
This is one powerful piece, Barb. I feel all of it but I’m more fortunate than most. Living a military dependents life has left me a very adaptable human. I count on nothing. I love your sister’s attitude. It’s pretty much how I handle things. Raise my vibration and pass it along to anyone I meet. I love Eileen’s comment. I walk with a cane and don’t you try and push me around or you’ll find yourself on the floor wondering what happened. I miss seeing my friends regularly and one of them is working out how we can get together. 6 ft apart inside her house?
My sister and I are both already facing terminal lung disease so we got an early start on all the grieving steps. She was in San Francisco yesterday hoping to be put on the transplant list. I’m not going there. I just don’t understand why there are so many good people gone and I’m still here. I am so glad my mother is already gone. She left Germany when she married my American soldier father and would be horrified to see the same patterns here in the states. I wonder if Germany will give me asylum? 😉 The hate cannot be remedied with more hate. Love has to win. You are so well traveled, you already know this. Thanks for sharing this wonderful wake up.
LikeLike
This is downright poetic, Barb. Thank you for expressing so eloquently what we are all dealing with.
I’m trying to remain hopeful. I WILL someday rent a cottage on the island and spend a few weeks writing and visiting with you!
Love Eileen’s grocery store story! I am tucking away that tactic just in case I need it. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
When I encounter YOBS like that, I try to remind myself of how I saw really old people (say, those over 40) when I was a teenager. I remember a trip to Paris where all the little old ladies dressed in black seemed to have a total hate on for me. It was soon mutual…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Dear Barb, I’ve been such a lurker … but always checking in to see how, what and where you are doing whatever. And love that you continue to write always with such perception and humour. This is a fine post in so many ways and I am about to share it. When our lives (along with everyone else in the world) came to a screeching halt in March, after a few months of lockdown with our beautiful city of Toronto inaccessible in so many ways, we moved two hours north to the skiing/sailing area of southern Ontario. There have been 19 cases of Covid here (total) and no deaths. We live surrounded by nature and have family and friends up here too. I still live in hope of returning to France one day, but in the meantime our Covid decision has definitely been the right move for us. I trust the situation is much the same (or better) on your lovely isle. Stay well. Your sister has the right attitude … may we all emulate it. Bisous
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well done you for braving the move! I wish I was still on Arran. Until this week, they haven’t had any cases of the virus. There are a few now, but still seems to be well controlled. But am I there? Um… We moved to Italy for the academic year. I am exploring cautiously (exteriors and outdoors only), and everyone here seems very dedicated to mask wearing. Fingers-crossed we’ll all make it to the end of 2020!
LikeLike
Pingback: 2020: goodbye and good riddance #NewYear #Coronavirus | Barb Taub
Barb, I just read this. What a thoughtul, insightful and caring post. Our daughter, who’s a drama teacher outside of Toronto, has been saying for a long time, the cost of this pandemic in mental health for adults and children is enormous and we’ll be dealing with the fallout for years to come. I’d like to think that we’ve become kinder, but stress brings out the worst in some people.
However, I’m an optimist, a half-glass full person. I’ve seen many people, young and old, benefit from the pandemic in suprising ways. The pandemic made them slow down. They noticed nature more and their spouses, children and pets. A realignment took place. Because everyone was in the same boat, there was reduced competition, and therefore, less stress. And people had time to protest a number of important issues plaguing all of us, like racism.
Fortunately, I still have my bliss being a writer, so that part of my life didn’t change.
I do hope and pray we all get out of this soon. I miss travelling freely and seeing so many people I love.
Stay well. Hope you and your family are weathering this difficult time.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you so much for this thoughtful comment. And best wishes to you and your family!
LikeLike